Chair (Milliken, Nicholas)
Alberta Health Services (authority)
Presentation on Public Health Act, relevance, points of order raised ... PHR64, 70
Canadian Civil Liberties Association (CCLA)
Presentation on Public Health Act, relevance, points of order raised ... PHR58
Chief medical officer of health
Presentation on Public Health Act, relevance, point of order ... PHR80 Presentation on Public Health Act, relevance, point of order raised ... PHR77
Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms
Public Health Act review, written responses to questions ... PHR86
Ministry of Health
Public Health Act review, written responses to questions ... PHR86
Motions (procedure)
Public Health Act review, recommendation that government explore options to include provisions to provide briefings on public health emergency orders to Official Opposition and any other Member of the Legislative Assembly (Rowswell: carried as amended), amendment to add "and any other Member of the Legislative Assembly" after "Official Opposition," leave to move motion sought (granted) ... PHR163 Public Health Act review, recommendation that section 52.1 be amended regarding (a) publication of orders, (b) ministerial authority, and (c-e) role of Legislature (Rosin: carried as amended), amendment to clause (a) to add "(within three hours)" after "immediately," leave to move motion sought (granted) ... PHR115 Public Health Act review, recommendation that section 52.1 be amended regarding (a) publication of orders, (b) ministerial authority, and (c-e) role of Legislature (Rosin: carried as amended), amendment to clause (a) to replace "under the act that all orders be made" with "that the Minister of Justice make all orders," leave to move motion sought (granted) ... PHR116 Public Health Act review, recommendation that section 52.1 be amended regarding (a) publication of orders, (b) ministerial authority, and (c-e) role of Legislature (Rosin: carried as amended), amendment to strike clause (a) and replace with alternative wording, leave to move motion sought (granted) ... PHR110 Public Health Act review, recommendation that section 52.1 be amended regarding (a) publication of orders, (b) ministerial authority, and (c-e) role of Legislature (Rosin: carried as amended), amendment to strike clause (a) and replace with alternative wording (Hoffman: defeated), subamendment to add "in plain language," leave to move motion sought (granted) ... PHR112 Public Health Act review, recommendation that section 52.1 be amended regarding (a) publication of orders, (b) ministerial authority, and (c-e) role of Legislature (Rosin: carried as amended), amendment to strike clause (a) and replace with alternative wording (Hoffman: defeated), subamendment to strike "in respect of a public health emergency," leave to move motion sought (granted) ... PHR112 Public Health Act review, stakeholder invitations (Hoffman: ruled out of order) ... PHR16 Public Health Act review, stakeholder invitations, committee to invite CMOH to reappear (Nielsen: carried), status of motion ... PHR90
Public Health Act
2016 amendments ... PHR34 Definitions, recommendation that act be amended to define "in the public interest," "extraordinary circumstances," and "significant threat," motion on (Neudorf: carried), recorded vote ... PHR153-54 Definitions, recommendation that act be amended to define "in the public interest," "extraordinary circumstances," and "significant threat," motion on (Neudorf: carried), relevance, points of order raised ... PHR151-52 Orders, ministerial, recommendation that act be amended to limit authority to alter or suspend legislation, motion on (Shepherd: defeated), recorded vote ... PHR121 Orders, ministerial, recommendation that act be amended to require Justice minister to issue legal opinions attesting to constitutionality of orders, motion on (Shepherd: defeated), recorded vote ... PHR125 Scope of act, recommendation that act be amended to include access to abortion services, motion on (Ganley: defeated), imputing motives, points of order raised ... PHR137-38 Scope of act, recommendation that act be amended to include access to abortion services, motion on (Ganley: defeated), recorded vote ... PHR144-45 Scope of act, recommendation that act be amended to include access to abortion services, motion on (Ganley: defeated), repetition, point of order raised ... PHR139 Scope of act, recommendation that act be amended to include access to medical assistance in dying services, motion on (Hoffman: defeated), recorded vote ... PHR149 Scope of act, recommendation that act be amended to include powers and duties to deal with opioid and other deadly substance use, motion on (Shepherd: defeated), recorded vote ... PHR105-6 Scope of act, recommendation that act be amended to recognize importance of universal public health care services, motion on (Ganley/Shepherd: defeated), recorded vote ... PHR132 Section 13, appointment of chief medical officer, recommendation that act be amended to establish CMOH as officer of the Legislature, motion on (Shepherd: defeated), recorded vote ... PHR158 Section 38(1), immunization by order in council, recommendation that act be amended to repeal section 38(1)(c), motion on (Reid: carried unanimously), recorded vote ... PHR133 Section 52.1, state of public health emergency, recommendation that act be amended regarding (a) publication of orders, (b) ministerial authority, and (c-e) role of Legislature, motion on (Rosin: carried as amended), amendment to clause (a) to add "(within three hours)" after "immediately," leave to move motion sought (granted) ... PHR115 Section 52.1, state of public health emergency, recommendation that act be amended regarding (a) publication of orders, (b) ministerial authority, and (c-e) role of Legislature, motion on (Rosin: carried as amended), amendment to clause (a) to add "including the government of Alberta website" after "online" and before "immediately," leave to move motion sought (granted) ... PHR116 Section 52.1, state of public health emergency, recommendation that act be amended regarding (a) publication of orders, (b) ministerial authority, and (c-e) role of Legislature, motion on (Rosin: carried as amended), amendment to clause (a) to replace "under the act that all orders be made" with "that the Minister of Justice make all orders," leave to move motion sought (granted) ... PHR116 Section 52.1, state of public health emergency, recommendation that act be amended regarding (a) publication of orders, (b) ministerial authority, and (c-e) role of Legislature, motion on (Rosin: carried as amended), amendment to strike clause (a) and replace with alternative wording, leave to move motion sought (granted) ... PHR110 Section 52.1, state of public health emergency, recommendation that act be amended regarding (a) publication of orders, (b) ministerial authority, and (c-e) role of Legislature, motion on (Rosin: carried as amended), amendment to strike clause (a) and replace with alternative wording, motion on (Hoffman: defeated) ... PHR110-11 Section 52.1, state of public health emergency, recommendation that act be amended regarding (a) publication of orders, (b) ministerial authority, and (c-e) role of Legislature, motion on (Rosin: carried as amended), amendment to strike clause (a) and replace with alternative wording, motion on (Hoffman: defeated), recorded vote ... PHR114 Section 52.1, state of public health emergency, recommendation that act be amended regarding (a) publication of orders, (b) ministerial authority, and (c-e) role of Legislature, motion on (Rosin: carried as amended), amendment to strike clause (a) and replace with alternative wording, motion on (Hoffman: defeated), subamendment to add "in plain language," leave to move motion sought (granted) ... PHR112 Section 52.1, state of public health emergency, recommendation that act be amended regarding (a) publication of orders, (b) ministerial authority, and (c-e) role of Legislature, motion on (Rosin: carried as amended), amendment to strike clause (a) and replace with alternative wording, motion on (Hoffman: defeated), subamendment to add "in plain language," motion on (Shepherd: defeated) ... PHR111-12 Section 52.1, state of public health emergency, recommendation that act be amended regarding (a) publication of orders, (b) ministerial authority, and (c-e) role of Legislature, motion on (Rosin: carried as amended), amendment to strike clause (a) and replace with alternative wording, motion on (Hoffman: defeated), subamendment to strike "in respect of a public health emergency," leave to move motion sought (granted) ... PHR112 Section 52.1, state of public health emergency, recommendation that act be amended regarding (a) publication of orders, (b) ministerial authority, and (c-e) role of Legislature, motion on (Rosin: carried as amended), recorded vote ... PHR117 Section 52.1, state of public health emergency, recommendation that government explore options to include provisions to provide briefings on orders to Official Opposition and any other Member of the Legislative Assembly, motion on (Rowswell: carried as amended) ... PHR163 Section 52.1, state of public health emergency, recommendation that government explore options to include provisions to provide briefings on orders to Official Opposition and any other Member of the Legislative Assembly, motion on (Rowswell: carried as amended), amendment to add "and any other Member of the Legislative Assembly" after "Official Opposition," leave to move motion sought (granted) ... PHR163 Section 52.21, ministerial orders during pandemic, relevance, point of order raised ... PHR24
Public Health Act review
Committee deliberation procedure ... PHR100-102 Committee deliberations ... PHR102, 110-13, 115-17 Committee report ... PHR163-65 Committee work plan, preparation of ... PHR94 Focus of review ... PHR2 Focus of review, subcommittee report recommendation, committee to approve recommendation 3.1, motion on (Reid: carried) ... PHR19 Focus of review, subcommittee report recommendations ... PHR19 Meeting agendas, posting of draft agendas 48 hours prior to meetings, motion on (Shepherd: defeated) ... PHR94-95 Meeting agendas, posting of draft agendas 48 hours prior to meetings, motion on (Shepherd: defeated), recorded vote ... PHR97 Research requests, research services to prepare a crossjurisdictional comparison on sections of PHA identified by committee, motion on (Reid: carried) ... PHR15 Research requests, research services to prepare issues document, motion on (Reid: carried), amendment to specify format of document, motion on (Hoffman: defeated) ... PHR92-93 Subcommittee activity ... PHR10 Subcommittee establishment ... PHR4 Subcommittee establishment, motion to rescind previous motion on subcommittee establishment (Rosin: carried) ... PHR12 Subcommittee establishment, motion to revert to discussing previous motion on subcommittee establishment (Rosin: carried unanimously) ... PHR12 Subcommittee establishment to, among other things, propose the focus of review and organize review process, motion on (Rosin: carried) ... PHR13, 15 Subcommittee establishment to, among other things, propose the focus of review and organize review process, motion on (Rosin: carried), amendment to have Hansard record subcommittee meetings and to make public the written or audio records, motion on (Hoffman: defeated) ... PHR13 Subcommittee establishment to, among other things, propose the focus of review and organize review process, motion on (Rosin: carried), amendment to have Hansard record subcommittee meetings and to make public the written or audio records, motion on (Hoffman: defeated), relevance, points of order raised ... PHR14 Subcommittee establishment to define focus of review and organize review process, motion on (Reid: carried) ... PHR4 Subcommittee establishment to define focus of review and organize review process, motion on (Reid: carried), amendment to strike out "the chair, three members of the government caucus, and two members of the Official Opposition" and substitute "one member of the government caucus and one member of the Official Opposition," motion on (Hoffman: defeated) ... PHR4 Subcommittee establishment to define focus of review and organize review process, motion on (Reid: carried), recorded vote ... PHR6 Subcommittee membership ... PHR6-7 Technical briefing ... PHR6-8, 10 Technical briefing, committee to invite officials from Health ministry to provide briefing on issues identified by the committee, motion on (Lovely: carried as amended) ... PHR9-12 Technical briefing, committee to invite officials from Health ministry to provide briefing on issues identified by the committee, motion on (Lovely: carried as amended), amendment to strike "the subcommittee to," motion on (Ganley: carried) (tie vote) ... PHR11 Technical briefing, committee to invite officials from Health ministry to provide briefing on issues identified by the committee, motion on (Lovely: carried as amended), amendment to strike "the subcommittee to," motion on (Ganley: carried) (tie vote), recorded vote ... PHR11-12 Technical briefing, committee to invite the Premier, Minister and Deputy Minister of Health, CEO of AHS, CMOH, Minister and Deputy Minister of Justice, Minister and Deputy Minister of Labour and Immigration, motion on (Hoffman: defeated) ... PHR8 Technical support ... PHR34 Technical support, committee to request that Health ministry officials work with LAO staff to support committee as requested during Public Health Act review, motion on (Turton: carried) ... PHR35 Timeline ... PHR2
Public Health Act review, public input
Written submissions, committee to authorize communications services to solicit submissions from public, motion on (Gray: carried) ... PHR41, 43 Written submissions, committee to make submissions available to the public ... PHR87 Written submissions, committee to make submissions available to the public, motion on (Rosin: carried) ... PHR87 Written submissions, public engagement ... PHR41 Written submissions, subcommittee report recommendation ... PHR40 Written submissions summary ... PHR86
Public Health Act review, stakeholder input
Stakeholder invitations, committee to authorize subcommittee to develop and recommend a stakeholder list for committee's approval by July 15, 2020, motion on (Long: debate adjourned) ... PHR17 Stakeholder invitations, committee to authorize subcommittee to develop and recommend a stakeholder list for committee's approval by July 15, 2020, motion on (Long: debate adjourned), amendment to replace "report back" with "recommend that stakeholder list," motion on (Ganley: carried) ... PHR17 Stakeholder invitations, committee to invite CMOH to reappear, motion on (Nielsen: carried) ... PHR83 Stakeholder invitations, committee to invite CMOH to reappear, motion on (Nielsen: carried), status of motion ... PHR90 Stakeholder invitations, committee to rescind motion to invite CMOH to reappear and commence deliberations at next meeting, leave to move motion sought (granted) ... PHR87-88 Stakeholder invitations, committee to rescind motion to invite CMOH to reappear and commence deliberations at next meeting, motion on (Schow: carried), recorded vote ... PHR92 Stakeholder invitations, motion on (Hoffman: ruled out of order) ... PHR16 Stakeholder list ... PHR15 Stakeholder list, subcommittee report recommendation ... PHR35 Stakeholder list, subcommittee report recommendation, committee to approve recommendation 3.2, motion on (Neudorf: carried) ... PHR39-40 Stakeholder list, subcommittee report recommendation, committee to approve recommendation 3.2, motion on (Neudorf: carried), amendment to add ", or written submissions if they are unable to appear in person" after "oral presentations" and invitations to a number of representatives and officials, motion on (Shepherd: defeated), imputing motives, point of order raised ... PHR38 Stakeholder list, subcommittee report recommendation, committee to approve recommendation 3.2, motion on (Neudorf: carried), amendment to add ", or written submissions if they are unable to appear in person" after "oral presentations" and invitations to a number of representatives and officials, motion on (Shepherd: defeated), procedure on motions, point of clarification ... PHR36-37
Public Health Act review, stakeholder oral presentations
Presentation time ... PHR47
Public Health Act review, summary of issues and proposals (research document)
Overview ... PHR99-100 Research services to prepare document ... PHR92 Research services to prepare document, motion on (Reid: carried) ... PHR92, 94
Public Health Act Review Committee, Select Special
Administrative support ... PHR2 Approval of September 18, 2020, agenda, motion on (Turton: carried as amended) ... PHR85-86 Approval of September 18, 2020, agenda, motion on (Turton: carried as amended), amendment to add committee work plan, motion on (Hoffman: carried) ... PHR85-86 Authorization for chair to approve minutes of September 29 and 30, 2020, meetings, motion on (Neudorf: carried) ... PHR165 Communications services support ... PHR2 Mandate ... PHR1-2, 64, 88 Procedure, imputing motives, points of order raised ... PHR38, 137-38 Procedure, motions in committee ... PHR8, 83, 87-88, 94-95, 108-11, 114, 116-18, 122, 134 Procedure, motions in committee, point of clarification ... PHR36-37 Procedure, motions in committee ruled out of order ... PHR16, 94, 97 Procedure, relevance, point of order ... PHR80 Procedure, relevance, points of order raised ... PHR14, 24, 58, 64, 70, 77, 151-52 Procedure, repetition, point of order raised ... PHR139 Procedure, supplemental questions ... PHR53, 63 Research services support ... PHR2, 15 Tele- or video conferencing permitted for the duration of committee's mandate, motion on (Shepherd: carried) ... PHR1
Cohen, Mitchell, QC (Counsel, Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms, Participant, Public Health Act Review)
Constitution Act, 1867
Division of powers ... PHR48 Section 55, royal assent ... PHR48
Courthouses
Accessibility during public health emergency ... PHR51, 53
Courts, provincial
Response to Jordan decision ... PHR53
Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms
Constitutional challenge to Bill 10 (2020) ... PHR49-53 Presentation on Public Health Act ... PHR48-53
Public Health Act
2020 amendments, constitutionality ... PHR48-52 Orders, appeals ... PHR51 Orders, chief medical officer ... PHR49 Orders, ministerial ... PHR48-49 Orders, publication of ... PHR49-50, 52 Powers, emergency, and individual rights ... PHR49-50 Public interest, definition, member's request for written response ... PHR53 Section 52.83, nonapplication of Regulations Act ... PHR49, 52 Section 53(4.2), information disclosure to police services ... PHR48-50
Public health laws
Constitutional compliance ... PHR51
Regulations Act
Section 3, publication ... PHR49
|